Developing animal theology : an engagement with Leonardo Boff

Abstract

This thesis seeks to develop animal theology in dialogue with Leonardo Boff,
specifically in relation to his liberation, ecological, and contextual theologies.
Through an examination of his major works relating to creation—notably, Jesus
Christ Liberator: A Critical Christology of Our Time (1972), Saint Francis: A Model
for Human Liberation (1981), Ecology and Liberation: A New Paradigm (1993), and
Cry of the Earth, Cry of the Poor (1995)—this thesis unravels the anthropocentric and
instrumentalist thinking that characterises Roman Catholic thought about animals. In
Jesus Christ Liberator, the work of Christ is considered only in relation to humanity,
which in practical terms means that human beings—their life, worth, and destiny—are
God’s primary, if not exclusive, concern. In Saint Francis, despite the obvious moral
example provided, Boff almost wholly ignores Francis’s significance for other
creatures, and his ecological theology tantalisingly remains insufficiently attentive to
the animal issue.

Yet Boff’s ecological theology represents a significant shift, and at least
notionally, he accepts the rights of other creatures. So paradoxically, his ecological
theology is a catalyst for greater concern for creation, including animals. Boff may
have influenced the thinking of Pope Francis, especially in the pope’s Laudato Si’
(2015), and has certainly engendered greater theological thinking on the environment.
Finally, this thesis proposes a non-anthropocentric reconstruction of the Trinity as
Gentleness, Solidarity, and Fraternity, reinforced by Boff’s work in Trinity and
Society (1986) and Holy Trinity, Perfect Community (1988). A Trinitarian theology of
animal liberation is suggested based on, inter alia, the notion of communion as being
“for” creation and the idea of Triune sight. The Trinity is proposed as a model for
human–animal relations.

Date of Award	Jun 2020
Original language	English
Awarding Institution	University of St Andrews
Supervisor	Mario I Aguilar (Supervisor)